Psycho Bob Reviews Quigley Down Under

As co-host, producer, sound engineer, morale officer, and occasional destroyer of unattended houseplants, I spend a lot of time studying important cultural artifacts. Some cats chase mice. I review books and movies.

Today, we're talking about Quigley Down Under, a movie that answers a question nobody knew they had: "What if a cowboy with a giant rifle went to Australia and started solving problems?" The answer is two hours of cinematic goodness.

The film stars Tom Selleck as Matthew Quigley, an American sharpshooter who travels to Australia after accepting a job offer from a wealthy ranch owner. Like many jobs, the description turns out to be somewhat misleading. Most people discover their employer isn't what they expected after the first staff meeting. Quigley discovers it after crossing an ocean.

As it turns out, the ranch owner is Elliott Marston, played by the always magnificent Alan Rickman. Rickman had a rare gift. He could walk into a room, smile politely, and somehow make everyone uncomfortable. Marston is sophisticated, wealthy, intelligent, and about as trustworthy as a cat promising not to knock something off a shelf. Speaking of shelves, I regret nothing.

What immediately stands out about Quigley Down Under is Tom Selleck. This isn't Magnum P.I. with a bigger hat. Selleck creates a hero who is calm, capable, and confident without being obnoxious. Quigley doesn't spend the movie bragging about how tough he is. He simply demonstrates it repeatedly.

Quigley carries a Sharps rifle so massive it looks like something designed specifically to hunt dinosaurs. The first time he demonstrates what that rifle can do, every man in the vicinity suddenly realizes they have made poor life choices. I know the feeling. It's the same look humans get when they realize they left a tuna sandwich unattended near me.

The Australian Outback deserves its own award. The landscape is enormous. Endless horizons stretch in every direction. Watching this movie feels like someone combined a classic Western with a nature documentary and then added Alan Rickman for flavor.

Director Simon Wincer makes the most of every dusty plain, rocky ridge, and blazing sunset. The Outback becomes a character all its own—beautiful, dangerous, and capable of making you question your GPS choices.

The film also benefits greatly from Laura San Giacomo as Crazy Cora. She brings humor, vulnerability, and heart to the story. Her chemistry with Selleck feels genuine and helps balance the action with emotional depth.

Now, being Psycho Bob, I usually prefer movies involving explosions, questionable decisions, and at least one character yelling, "This is a terrible idea!" Fortunately, Quigley Down Under delivers. The action scenes are fantastic. The shootouts feel earned. The tension builds naturally. And the final confrontation is one of the most satisfying payoffs in Western cinema. There is a particular moment near the end that never fails to make me grin like a cat who just discovered an unlocked pantry.

What I appreciate most is that Quigley is an old-school hero. He stands up for what's right because it's right. He doesn't need a tragic speech every ten minutes. He doesn't spend the entire movie questioning whether heroism matters. He simply sees injustice and decides somebody needs to do something about it. Imagine that.

The movie also addresses the mistreatment of Indigenous Australians, giving the story additional weight and reminding viewers that true courage isn't just about winning gunfights. Sometimes it's about standing against cruelty even when it would be easier to look away.

Now comes the part where Psycho Bob climbs onto his soapbox—or more accurately, onto the kitchen counter where he isn't supposed to be.

Quigley Down Under is criminally underrated and criminally underappreciated. For reasons I will never fully understand, this film rarely gets mentioned alongside the great modern Westerns. When people discuss memorable Western heroes, Quigley is often left out of the conversation. When people talk about great performances from Tom Selleck, this role should be at the top of the list. When people celebrate unforgettable villains, Alan Rickman's Elliott Marston deserves far more recognition than he receives.

This movie has everything Western fans claim to want: a charismatic hero, a villain you love to hate, spectacular scenery, memorable dialogue, exciting action, emotional depth, and a story that actually has something meaningful to say.

Yet somehow it remains one of Hollywood's best-kept secrets. That's a shame because Quigley Down Under isn't merely a good Western. It's a great Western. The kind of movie that gets better every time you watch it. The kind of movie that reminds you why the Western genre became popular in the first place. And the kind of movie that deserves far more love than it has received over the past three decades.

For me, Quigley Down Under hits all the right notes. It has a heroic lead, a wonderfully evil villain, stunning scenery, memorable dialogue, and enough rifle-based problem solving to satisfy even the most demanding Western fan.

Shakin Shaner often talks about finding movies that hold up decades later. This one absolutely does. In fact, after everything he's survived—including heart failure, multiple heart attacks, and strokes—there's something especially appealing about a hero who refuses to back down when life takes an unexpected shot at him. Quigley keeps moving forward. Shaner keeps moving forward. And as a cat who has allegedly used several of his nine lives already, I can appreciate that philosophy.

Final Verdict:

Quigley Down Under is not only one of the most underrated Westerns ever made—it is one of the most underappreciated films of its era. If you've somehow missed it, fix that immediately. If you've seen it before, saddle up for another viewing. Some movies deserve to be rediscovered. This one deserves to be celebrated.

Rating

Psycho Bob gives it 4.5 tuna cans out of 5. Now if you'll excuse me, I have important business to attend to.Specifically, knocking a pen off a desk and pretending gravity was my idea.

Streaming

We rewatched Quigley Down Under on Tubi.

Join us/Sign up/Catch our podcast

Every week, Whats Shakin With Shaner publishes a new blog/article on Wednesdays. Make sure you don't miss one and sign up today.

Join Here

To catch our bi-weekly podcast, "What' Shakin With Shaner", you can find us on Apple podcasts, Spotify, Goodpods, Podcast Addict, Amazon Music, Audible, I Heart Radio or at our website, shakinshaner.com. We publish a new episode every other Sunday.